How we review supplements
Every review follows the same method, so scores are comparable across brands and categories.
What we do, and what we don’t
Our reviews are evidence-led desk reviews. For each product we read the full label and the brand’s UK product page, compare every active ingredient’s dose with the doses used in human studies, check for independent testing, and work out what a day’s serving really costs.
We don’t run lab tests, and we don’t claim to have taken a product unless a named reviewer actually has. We never publish made-up customer quotes or star ratings.
How the score works
Every product is scored on a scale of 0 to 10. A 10 would mean the absolute best of the best: a product with top-quality research behind every ingredient, at the right doses, independently tested and fairly priced. In practice that product probably doesn’t exist, so even the best products we review score below 10. That’s simply how our scoring system works.
Each product gets four sub-scores out of 10. The overall score is a weighted average:
- Evidence (40%): how good the research in people is for the main ingredients, for the reasons people buy the product.
- Dose (20%): whether each ingredient is present at the amount studied. “Proprietary blends” that hide doses lose points.
- Quality and testing (20%): independent certification such as Informed Sport, clear labelling, sensible extras and the brand’s track record.
- Value (20%): full UK price per daily serving, compared with similar products. We use the standard price, not first-order discounts.
What the evidence grades mean
- Grade A: Well established Well established. Good research in people supports it for this use, or it carries an authorised UK health claim at this amount.
- Grade B: Good support Good support. Promising research in people, long-standing traditional use, or both.
- Grade C: Some support Some support. Early or limited research in people.
- Grade D: Little support Little support. Very little research for this use.
Grades look at each ingredient’s role in the product as a whole. Many of the products we review combine several ingredients at amounts designed for everyday use, so we don’t mark an ingredient down just because one study used a different amount. How much of each ingredient a product contains is covered separately by the dose score.
Which sources we trust
We prefer the NHS, the European Food Safety Authority, the US National Institutes of Health Office of Dietary Supplements, Cochrane reviews and peer-reviewed meta-analyses and randomised trials. Every review lists its sources so you can check them.
Prices
We check prices on the brand’s UK website or a major UK retailer and show the date we checked. Prices change, so always confirm before you buy.
Keeping reviews up to date
We revisit reviews when a formula, price or the research changes. The “updated” date at the top of each review shows when it was last checked.